Social Media for Nonprofits with Karri Morgan of Scott Hamilton CARES Foundation
Season THREE | Episode THIRTY TWO
Listen On Spotify
In Dose of Social Episode 32, Lindsay Mauch and Kayla Perlstein sit down with Karri Morgan, Executive Director of the Scott Hamilton Cares Foundation, and talk about what it actually takes to build awareness, drive engagement, and fundraise on social media without falling into “mission drift” or exhausting your audience with constant asks.
Karri works alongside Olympic gold medalist and cancer survivor Scott Hamilton, whose personal story is at the heart of the foundation’s purpose. Scott’s cancer journey and the gaps he experienced as a patient sparked programs like ChemoCare (breaking down complex cancer info into easy-to-understand language) and Fourth Angel (a “big brother/big sister” support system for patients who need someone who’s been there). Today, the foundation also funds immunotherapy research, a major focus Karri described as “sniper treatment versus grenade treatment,” with the goal of helping promising research move from bench to bedside and into clinical trials.
But this episode wasn’t just about the mission, it was about how to communicate a heavy topic on social media in a way that’s human, hopeful, and effective.
Social Media as Education and Hope
Karri shared that social media is an important “educational vehicle” for the Scott Hamilton CARES Foundation: teaching audiences about screenings and prevention, sharing human-interest stories, and keeping content aligned with Scott’s positive, values-led approach. Cancer is heavy and that’s exactly why the foundation works hard to lead with hope, inspiration, and momentum.
What Types of Social Media Content Perform Best for Non-Profits
Three themes consistently resonate:
- Behind-The-Scenes Content (especially around their signature event, Scott Hamilton & Friends)
- Survivor Stories (because everyone loves a redemption arc and a victory)
- Community Spotlights (donors, volunteers, and sponsors, and the people who make the mission possible)
Their live events create a ton of content opportunities, from rehearsals to backstage moments to emotional highlights on the ice. Karri also shared two standout “wins” that prove the power of organic storytelling:
- A heartfelt story shared on The Bobby Bones Show that sparked donations from across 30 states without the foundation even pushing it.
A viral moment tied to Scott’s iconic backflip and the foundation’s “Turn Cancer Upside Down” identity, including their upside-down cancer ribbon.
Listen On Youtube
The Fundraising Balance (and Donor Fatigue)
One of the most valuable parts of the conversation was Karri’s honesty about donor fatigue. With 30+ events a year across multiple states, the foundation has to constantly balance storytelling, gratitude, awareness, and asks for donation without overwhelming their community. They don’t follow a strict ratio, but they’re always mindful of the “donate, donate, donate” drumbeat.
They also discussed why “Sponsored” posts can feel tricky for non-profits: even if paid social is inexpensive, some donors worry about where funds are going or feel less connected to content that looks like an ad.
And sometimes? The best content is simply human. Karri’s proudest recent moment was a playful post about “voluntold” husbands. This was a post highlighting the spouses who always get recruited to help out at volunteer events for the foundation. It sparked real connection, and people even texted her to say how much they loved it.
Actionable Takeaways
- Lead with mission-first storytelling. Keep content hopeful and aligned with your values to avoid mission drift.
- Build content pillars that consistently work: behind-the-scenes, survivor stories, and community spotlights (donors/volunteers/sponsors).
- Plan ahead for donation asks and be mindful of donor fatigue. You don’t need a perfect formula, just be intentional about spacing out fundraising CTAs.
- Don’t underestimate organic moments. Leave room for community-driven stories to take off (and be ready to amplify them).
- Humanize your brand with gratitude and humor. Simple posts (like appreciating your “voluntold” helpers) can drive real engagement and deepen loyalty.
You can find the Scott Hamilton CARES Foundation on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com/teamscottcares.
Listen On Apple
❤️ Loving the show?
If you enjoyed this episode, please head over to Apple Podcasts and leave a rating. It takes less than a minute and helps us keep creating content.