Marketing & Social Media Talent How to Hire and Get Hired Like A Pro with Krissy Manzano
Season Two | Episode SIXTEEN
Listen On Spotify
In episode 16 of the Dose of Social podcast, Lindsay Mauch and Kayla Perlstein sit down with Krissy Manzano, co-founder of Blueprint Expansion, to talk about what actually makes a strong marketing or social media hire for small businesses and brands.
Krissy’s path to recruiting is anything but traditional. She started as a sales leader in SaaS startups and admits she once despised recruiters until she found herself running a recruiting firm five years later. After leading explosive growth at a startup (including building a Nashville office from one person to 100+ employees), she got a real taste of entrepreneurship. That experience, combined with becoming a new mom and pushing back on the limitations people often place on working women, fueled her decision to build a business on her own terms: strong outcomes, strong boundaries, and real work-life balance.
Today, Krissy’s team at Blueprint Expansion specializes in recruiting for sales, marketing, and customer success roles and she’s learned just how specialized marketing has become. She even joked that she owes marketers an apology, because the “natural tension” between sales and marketing often comes from a misunderstanding of how complex and nuanced marketing roles really are.
So what should small business owners do before hiring a social media manager?
Krissy’s answer is simple: start by identifying what your goals and needs are for this role. Many founders rush to hire without clarity. If your goal is lead generation, for example, hiring a social media manager alone may not solve that—because social media isn’t built primarily for direct lead gen. The role you hire should match the outcomes you want.
Krissy also emphasized something many small businesses overlook: you must be ready to hire. That means you have the time (and commitment) to onboard, train, and set clear expectations. Being “small” isn’t an excuse to skip structure. If you hire, onboarding becomes mission critical. Do you have Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) in place? If not, you better get working on them.
Listen On Youtube
When it comes to attracting better candidates, Krissy recommends building an Ideal Candidate Profile (ICP) before writing the job description. Most people copy job descriptions from LinkedIn, tweak a few lines, and unintentionally keep themselves in the same candidate funnel as everyone else. An ICP flips that by focusing on the skills, behaviors, and traits that actually predict success.
And for interviewing? Krissy loves asking candidates to explain real examples: what they owned, what results they delivered, and what they learned. She also shared the STAR method (Situation, Time, Action, Result) to keep answers clear and concise. But her biggest “green flag” is preparedness: candidates should understand your business well enough to explain your value proposition and ask smart follow-up questions. If someone can’t articulate what you do, why would you trust them to represent your brand?
Finally, Krissy confirms what many suspect: companies often check LinkedIn and other social media platforms, sometimes before they even look at a resume. For social media roles especially, your online presence DOES matter.
Actionable Takeaways
- Define your goals and needs before you hire. Write down the outcomes you want (brand awareness, content consistency, lead gen, etc.) and hire for that, not a vague “fix marketing” role.
- Build an Ideal Candidate Profile (ICP) first. Identify 3–5 key competencies (skills + behaviors) needed for success, then write your job description from that.
- Make onboarding non-negotiable. If you don’t have time to train and ramp someone up, you’re not ready to hire yet.
- Use pre-screen questions to save time. Ask 2–3 questions before scheduling interviews (pay expectations, why this company, quick writing sample) to filter faster.
- Interview by competency, not “vibes.” Assign specific competencies to each interview step, and add a practical exercise (even for junior roles) to see real skills in action.
You can find Krissy on social media at https://www.instagram.com/bp_gtm/
Listen On Apple
❤️ Loving the show?
If you enjoyed this episode, please head over to Apple Podcasts and leave a rating. It takes less than a minute and helps us keep creating content.